Healthy Aging
A Quiet Evening and a Difficult Decision
It was a fall evening. Mr. Oğuz had picked up his grandchild from school, as usual, with his car. However, on the way back, he hesitated briefly on familiar roads and stayed at the traffic lights much longer than necessary. There was no panic at home; but his daughter, Zeynep, after combining this recent lapse with a few minor accidents in the past, felt that the time had come. They were on the threshold of one of the most difficult family conversations: driving safety and the decision to stop driving…
Why Is This Topic So Challenging?
For many, being a driver is more than just getting from point A to B. It represents independence, confidence, participation in society, and is part of daily life. Especially in later years, the idea of giving up this habit can merge with feelings of identity loss and exclusion. According to data published by the Alzheimer's Association, 76% of people with dementia want to continue driving, while most families worry about this issue. Thus, especially in families where neurological diseases and age-related cognitive decline come to the fore, driving safety becomes more than a debate—it is an emotional test.
Neuroscience Perspective: Aging and Driving Ability
Brain health plays a defining role in complex activities like driving, which require multiple cognitive processes. Studies indicate that, as we age, attention spans shorten, reflexes slow down, and visuospatial skills decline (Source). In addition, neurological conditions such as dementia, Parkinson's disease, and stroke can significantly impair decision-making and reaction times that are vital for driving.
Accident risk in individuals over 65 is twice as high compared to younger drivers (CDC, 2022).
40% of Alzheimer’s patients still drive within 2 years of diagnosis (Source).
Mild impairments in the frontal lobe and parietal lobe of the brain can result in pronounced difficulties with sudden maneuvers or decision making at intersections.
Warning Signs That May Trigger the Decision to Stop Driving
Family members often begin to worry when they see several of the following signs together:
Frequently getting lost or confusing routes
An increase in minor scratches, dents, or traffic tickets
Showing stress, panic, or aggressive behavior when roads are closed in traffic
Not noticing or evaluating some road signs correctly
Observing issues with attention while driving (following other cars too closely, not signaling, etc.)
Of course, a single incident is not enough to make a decision. However, repeated and noticeable changes tend to prompt families to take a protective approach.
The Psychological and Emotional Aspects of Giving Up Driving
Driving is an important part of an individual's connection with their environment and everyday life. Giving it up can make a person face the fear of losing their independence. In this process,
Feelings of inadequacy
Fear of social exclusion
Reduction in interaction with social circles
Shaken self-confidence
are emotions that come to the forefront.
Some studies indicate that older adults who stop driving may display signs of anxiety or depression within the first three months (Source).
So, How Do You Start the Conversation?
You are not alone if you feel like Zeynep, Mr. Oğuz’s daughter. Discussing the decision to stop driving within the family is a highly sensitive process from both emotional and communication perspectives. Therefore:
Choose the right time: Don’t have the discussion in a rushed or emotionally charged moment; instead, opt for a calm, safe, and neutral environment.
Listen with empathy: Listen sincerely to their feelings and fears without minimizing them.
Search for solutions together: Putting transportation alternatives on the table makes the decision more acceptable.
Act with professional support: If needed, consult an impartial specialist such as a neurologist or psychologist to translate medical terms into the family’s common language.
Be clear and understandable: Express your concerns clearly, but avoid definitive, judgmental statements like “you can’t drive anymore.”
"Dad, we want you to feel good. We know this is a tough decision. We respect you and want to find solutions together."
Scientifically Proven Approaches: Balancing "Loss" and "Gain"
Behavioral science suggests that people often prefer to maintain their current situation instead of experiencing loss (“loss aversion principle”). Studies show that the emotional burden caused by giving up driving can be balanced by supporting other active areas in the person's life (Source). For example, dedicating time to personal interests, organizing group activities, or participating in volunteer projects can ease feelings of “deprivation.”
Alternative Transportation Methods and Family Support
The act of giving up driving does not have to mean ending one’s entire social life. Therefore, planning for alternative transportation and social support systems makes the process much less painful.
Public transportation: Access to public transport systems like subways and buses can increase independence.
Family and friend support: Family members can create a volunteer ride-sharing program.
Taxis, private ride-hailing apps: Using technology, especially in big cities, provides freedom of movement.
Volunteer transportation services: Some municipalities and NGOs offer free or discounted transportation plans for seniors which can be researched.
The Role of Family Members: Patience, Knowledge, Compassion
Many elderly individuals feel a sense of “control” while driving and maintain communication with their surroundings. The persuasion process to stop driving should not be rushed. The American Geriatrics Society recommends, “The emotional preparation process is expected to take at least 2 months” (Source). During these conversations, family members should:
Approach with respectful and exemplary language instead of blaming or pressuring
Explain their concerns using real incidents and examples
Emphasize that producing solutions together is more constructive
Allow time and provide emotional support
Involve a professional or an outside perspective (doctor, therapist) if necessary
When Should Doctors and Specialists Get Involved?
The issue of stopping driving can sometimes exceed a family’s capacity. Especially when dementia, Parkinson's disease, or other neurological conditions are present, medical advice can be vital. Research shows that having a doctor “provide scientific justification” helps facilitate the decision for older adults. In fact, some countries officially require driving assessment tests (Source).
Points to consider here:
Objective evaluation of driving competence through medical exams and psychometric tests
Consulting a neurologist or psychiatrist on the individual's legal rights and license status
Adopting the perspective, with expert recommendations, that “This is not just your decision, it is what must be done for health reasons.”
A Turning Point from Real Life: Mrs. Yıldız’s Story
Mrs. Yıldız, 72, a retired teacher and charming Istanbul lady, was diagnosed with dementia. Her son and daughter asked her to stop driving due to her declining attention. Initially, she refused the suggestion: “It’s my only way to go out.” But over time, she realized that walking with a neighbor and the weekend trips her children planned for her actually made her feel good. After four months, she understood she could be free even without a car.
Myths and Facts
“Only those who have accidents should stop driving” – False. Even mental warning signs without an accident may warrant stopping.
“Stopping driving cuts off social life” – Incomplete. With alternatives and family support, social engagement can be maintained.
“Applying pressure accelerates the decision” – False. Pressure only deepens resistance and stubbornness.
“Family can handle it without doctor input” – Limited. Unbiased expert support makes the process healthier.
Frequently Asked Questions
What if the person asked to stop driving is not convinced?
Don’t rush. Allow time. Seek professional advice if needed.Are brain MRIs or imaging tests decisive?
Findings on brain health can be supportive; however, the decision is usually made based on neurological examination and behavioral observation.What if conflict arises in the family during the decision process?
Consulting a neutral family counselor, neurologist, or psychologist is beneficial.
Step by Step: A Roadmap for a Healthy Decision
Assess cognitive health (neurologist appointment, psychometric tests)
Openly discuss the matter within the family. Allow time for emotions.
Include the whole family in planning alternative transportation options.
Seek expert guidance for a safe process.
Organize emotional and social support.
Obtain professional counseling if necessary.
Final Words: Approach with Compassion
Giving up driving can be more of a new beginning than a loss. Perhaps the most important reminder for families is this: When you act together with compassion and scientific guidance, you can get through this challenging period with less pain and with greater focus on the person.
References
Bir Sonraki Okuma
